The Carbon Trap: Carbon Dioxide Injections Stimulate Peculiar Subsurface Microbial Communities

Carbon capture and storage (CCS) is a strategy that aims to offset carbon dioxide created from burning fossil fuels by injecting this gas directly into the subsurface. In the case of mineral storage, the injections target certain types of volcanic rocks, so that the carbon dioxide will react with underground minerals to form long-lasting carbonate compounds. The efficiency and hence the long-term viability of mineral storage, however, is still in question. 

One aspect of CCS that some researchers have overlooked is the role of subsurface microbes. DCO members Rosalia Trias, Bénédicte Ménez, Paul le Campion, Aurélien Lecoeuvre, and Emmanuelle Gérard, (all at the Institut de Physique du Globe de Paris, France), examined how native microbial communities responded to the injection of carbon dioxide into a CCS pilot site adjacent to an Icelandic power plant. In a new paper in Nature Communications [1], the researchers describe how the injections created successive blooms in certain microbial species. The results suggest that, rather than fully solidifying into carbonate minerals, some of the carbon dioxide became bacterial biomass, which may impact the long-term success of carbon storage.

“The novelty of our study is to pay attention to the deep biological component in a carbon sequestration venture,” said Ménez. “This is a point generally missed in the currently developed approaches.”

“The novelty of our study is to pay attention to the deep biological component in a carbon sequestration venture,” said Ménez. “This is a point generally missed in the currently developed approaches.”

The study benefitted from a larger initiative, CarbFix , an international consortium involving Reykjavik Energy, Columbia University (USA), the University of Southampton (UK), the French CNRS, and researchers at the University of Iceland. This research consortium developed methods for safe, long-term storage of carbon dioxide within basalt, a reactive volcanic rock. To establish proof of concept, they injected carbon dioxide from the Hellisheidi Geothermal Power Plant in southwest Iceland into a well reaching 400 to 800 meters deep.

The first injection occurred in January 2012, and by mid-March of that year, due to the acidifying nature of carbon dioxide, the pH of the groundwater had dropped from 9.6 to 6.6. The IPGP group monitored the microbial community in the basalt by sequencing DNA from groundwater samples and detecting key genes for different metabolic processes. They compared their findings to a control well that had not received any carbon dioxide and to the original state of the aquifer prior to injection.

The acidic, carbon dioxide-rich water initially caused a decrease in the overall number of microbial species, but certain microbes thrived in these conditions. Iron and other ions, as well as possible polyaromatic hydrocarbons, were leached from the rock, which stimulated certain microbial groups. Bacteria that oxidize iron for energy and can assimilate inorganic carbon, and microbes that use carbon dioxide to degrade aromatic compounds, both experienced blooms. These population explosions suggest that some of the carbon dioxide became incorporated into bacterial biomass rather than, as expected, into stable carbonate minerals.

Furthermore, microorganisms used iron, magnesium, and calcium cations for their metabolism, which otherwise might react with the carbon dioxide to form solid carbonates. By controlling the redox state of the aquifer and the cation availability, enhanced microbial activities may also have impacted how efficiently silicate minerals dissolved and reacted with the carbon dioxide

“If we want safe, long-term storage of carbon dioxide as carbonate minerals, we must consider the impact of deep ecosystems,” said Gérard. “Storing carbon as biomass is undesirable because it is not stable and its movement cannot be controlled in the subsurface.”

The study also sheds some light on the diversity and activities of microbes inhabiting solid rock environments, which represents a giant but poorly understand habitat. Studies of the microbial communities living in carbon dioxide injection wells may not only guide future CCS efforts, but could also be useful for mimicking another fascinating subsurface habitat: the network of carbon dioxide-rich hydrothermal fluids that circulate within basaltic rocks at mid-ocean ridges.

The basalt field where carbon dioxide injection and storage occurred, In the background, the Hellisheidi geothermal power plant releases plumes of carbon dioxide-bearing volcanic gases. Credit: Bénédicte Ménez
Rosalia Trias examines the basalt rock cores drilled near the injection well, after carbon dioxide injections. Credit: Bénédicte Ménez

Further Reading

ethanogens Can’t Make It On Their Own in the Lost City
DCO Research Methanogens Can’t Make It On Their Own in the Lost City

DCO members Susan Lang (University of South Carolina, USA) Gretchen Früh-Green, Stefano Bernasconi…

Microbial Evolution in the Hot Seat
DCO Research Microbial Evolution in the Hot Seat

The hot, mineral-rich fluids circulating within hydrothermal vent systems along the seafloor are…

DCO Research Deep Microbes Thrive in Baltic Sea Sediments

The Baltic Sea has had a dramatic geologic past, complete with advancing and retreating glaciers…

rachael hazael
DCO Research Bacteria May Survive the Shock of Interplanetary Travel

Investigating life in the deep subsurface has lead to the discovery of bacterial species thriving…

Back to top